Canadian giving isn't collapsing — but the bar for earning it has quietly gotten a lot higher. In our latest study, we surveyed 1,000 Canadians to understand not just how much they give, but the decision mechanics behind who gets their dollars and why. The findings point to a sector at an inflection point: donors haven't stopped caring, they've just stopped giving anyone the benefit of the doubt.

‍

The headline tension is trust. While 53% of Canadians donated in the past year, rising costs have made every dollar feel more consequential — and 78% of Canadians report juggling at least three distinct barriers to giving at once, from not knowing where their money goes to feeling asked for support everywhere they turn. Emotional appeals still work (35% of donors were acquired through a moment that genuinely moved them, and more than 60% of them would give again), but the old guilt-driven playbook is losing its grip: 57% of Canadians, including most current donors, say they're tired of it. The fix isn't abandoning story, it's pairing it with proof. Meanwhile, proximity turns out to be one of the strongest levers in the entire study — causes that feel local and tangible are prioritized five times more often than causes that feel distant or abstract, and generational divides run deeper than channel preference: Gen Z hesitates because it wants credibility signals, Boomers hesitate because they feel over-asked.

‍

For organizations navigating 2026, the through-line across all of this is the same question donors are now silently asking every time an ask lands in their inbox or mailbox: not "should I give?" but "why you?" That's the shift worth building strategy around, and it's exactly the kind of why-behind-the-data work we do at Flesh & Bone — our approach to synthesizing what people say with what actually drives their decisions is what surfaced these patterns in the first place, rather than just reporting the topline stats.

‍

Download the full report →